Who do you think were GH's best - and - worse recasts?

Steven Webber has to be the worst he lost a whole foot when they recasted him

Coltin Scott as Nikolas was bad, as was Andrea Parsons as Gia.

Jacob Young is a great JR on AMC, but he was by far, the WORST thing to ever happen to the character of Lucky Spencer.

Best:
Genie Francis as Laura
Coltin Scott as Nikolas
Kristen Storm as Maxie
Tamara Braun and Laura Wright as Carly
Robin Mattson as Heather
Billy Warlock as AJ (didn't like him at first, but I soon warmed to his version)

Worse:
Jacob Young and Greg Vaughan as Lucky
Jed Allen as Edward (what were they thinking???)
Natalia Livingston as Emily
Sandra Ferguson as Felicia

Best: Tamara Braun as Carly

Worst: Laura Wright as Carly

lets face the new michael sucks bad hey chris why am i having such trouble with the similes

Jacob Young as Lucky for me and Natalie Livingston. Once they took her out of Chad Brannon's orbit, I realized how horrible of a recast she was.

Also hated when they brought Tyler Christopher back - hated how GH went about it, entering into negotiations with Coltin, all the while trying to woo Tyler back. Tyler was an okay actor when surrounded by a stellar cast - Stephen Nichols, Tony Geary, JJ - but take that away, and Tyler just wasn't convincing when he returned as Nikolas. I quit GH not long after Tyler came back - hated the direction of the show was heading in and had been hanging on only for Chad Brannon and when he left, I turned my back on GH. Maybe Natalie and Tyler improved after I quit but I do know that their "love" scenes were enough to make me want to loose my lunch - that one scene with the red light strobing in the background? Tyler licking his way up Natalia's leg like a starved man devouring a hamburger? I quit on Chad's last day and the only eppy I've watched scene was the day Chad appeared again on the plane on Natalia's last day.

Horrible re-casts for me:

Jacob Young
Natalie Livingston
Tyler Christopher in the re-recast.

Worst, the third Carly, can't remember her name was just awful. The latest Michael and Morgan are bad, bad, bad. Any Lucky but JJ just did not work for me. Best, TB did very well as Carly. The present Edward does well although no one could replace David Lewis.

I liked TB as Carly. It's funny - while I loved SB, I hated Carly while she played her. It wasn't until TB took over that I started liking Carly, but it didn't last once she fell under Sonny's influence again.

The third Carly - didn't a GL actress take over?

Her name is Jennifer Bransford and she played Georgie Philips on OLTL. I don't see anything listed that she has done since her GH role. She was okay as Georgie but was terrible as Carly.

Okay - so she took over from TB, and then the GL actress whose name I can't remember took over form her?

I think the worst recast was Jacob Young as Lucky but they have always done great recast as Carly.