CC33

Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

CC33


+6
Shale
Alan Smithee
MandyPerfumeGirl
Nystyle709
CeCe
Chris
10 posters

    Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Chris
    Chris
    Chamber Admin.
    Chamber Admin.


    Male
    Join date : 2010-01-30
    Location : Oak Park, Michigan
    Posts : 23201
    Rep : 330

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by Chris Wed Apr 27, 2011 7:02 am

    Do you think actors should be cast to play roles of characters who fall outside of their race and/or ethnic group? For instance, it's not uncommon to see Hispanic playing African-American, or Jewish actors playing Italian. What do you think, does it matter? Can it be seen as a mockery, does it make the role disingenuous?
    CeCe
    CeCe
    …is a Chamber DEITY.
    …is a Chamber DEITY.


    Join date : 2010-06-30
    Posts : 11962
    Rep : 326

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Re: Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by CeCe Wed Apr 27, 2011 8:33 am

    It probably depends on the actor. Pacino was great as Tony Montana. But I don't like seeing people wearing make up to pull it off. I understand why they did it in the old days of Hollywood, like "The Ten Commandments" or the old westerns but there are certainly enough actors of all ethnicities now that it just isn't necessary anymore.
    Nystyle709
    Nystyle709
    ...is a 20G Chamber DIETY.
    ...is a 20G Chamber DIETY.


    Female
    Join date : 2010-03-16
    Location : New York
    Posts : 27030
    Rep : 339

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Re: Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by Nystyle709 Wed Apr 27, 2011 6:15 pm

    Typically, no. If the role calls for a black woman, then hire a black actress. If the role calls for a Latina, hire a Latina actress. I think that with white actors and actresses they can pull that off if they or the role is ambiguous enough but I really don't care to see a white woman/man play a black woman/man and vice versa. Esp if you have to 'make' them up. Doesn't make sense.
    MandyPerfumeGirl
    MandyPerfumeGirl
    …is a Power Member.
    …is a Power Member.


    Female
    Join date : 2010-05-31
    Location : Illinois
    Posts : 1273
    Rep : 26

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Re: Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by MandyPerfumeGirl Sat Apr 30, 2011 1:40 pm

    I don't think it's a bad idea for actors to play roles outside their race and I certainly don't think it makes a mockery of either the actor or the character. If the actor can pull it off, then go for it. And if you're a good enough actor, nobody will think about it.
    Alan Smithee
    Alan Smithee
    ...is a 20G Chamber DIETY.
    ...is a 20G Chamber DIETY.


    Male
    Join date : 2010-09-03
    Location : 40º44’18.33”N 73º58’31.82”W
    Posts : 25792
    Rep : 381

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Re: Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by Alan Smithee Sat Apr 30, 2011 1:56 pm

    On a new show, Chicago Code, it was shown that Jennifer Beals' character's father and sister are black. Jennifer Beals is bi-racial but she looks more "white" than Pres. Obama. People who don't know her heritage are probably saying, "Oh come on!" Actually, I think they'd be entitled to because the actress who played her sister would not "pass" for white. I'm glad that we don't have white actors playing Indians and Asians as Sam Jaffe, Paul Muni and Katherine Hepburn (for example) did at one time. LOL, James (Sonny Corleone) Caan once told that an American-Italian group once tried to give him an award for something because they didn't know he was Jewish.
    Shale
    Shale
    ...is a Chamber Royal.
    ...is a Chamber Royal.


    Male
    Join date : 2010-09-27
    Location : Miami Beach
    Posts : 9699
    Rep : 219

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Re: Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by Shale Sat Apr 30, 2011 1:59 pm

    Chris wrote:Do you think actors should be cast to play roles of characters who fall outside of their race and/or ethnic group? ...
    You mean like this Asian actor who played the King of Siam?

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Brynner%203

    Or Charlie Chan?

    Actors playing characters outside their race. 185px-Warner_Oland

    Warner Oland - Swede
    big grin
    captainbryce
    captainbryce
    …is a Power Member.
    …is a Power Member.


    Male
    Join date : 2010-04-11
    Location : California
    Posts : 2051
    Rep : 127

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Re: Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by captainbryce Sat Apr 30, 2011 3:38 pm

    Chris wrote:Do you think actors should be cast to play roles of characters who fall outside of their race and/or ethnic group? For instance, it's not uncommon to see Hispanic playing African-American, or Jewish actors playing Italian. What do you think, does it matter? Can it be seen as a mockery, does it make the role disingenuous?
    I think if the actor looks close enough to the race or ethnicity he/she is playing and the performance comes off as believable, then I don't have a problem with it. Jenette Goldstien is a Jewish American actress who played Pvt. Vasquez (a Hispanic character) in the film Aliens and an Irish mother in the film Titanic. I didn't even realize it was the same actress until years later because she was able to play both roles completely convincingly. I swore that the actress playing "Vasquez" was Puerto Rican for years. In the film Tropic Thunder, Robert Downey Jr. played an Australian character "playing" an African American character. Once again, he was totally convincing at his role (and his role withing the role) and it was hilarious. So I don't have a problem with actors doing this if they are convincing. On the other hand, if they could obviously never get away with portraying the character due to their appearance or acting skills, then of course not!

    Examples where actors should never have attempted this: David Carradine, playing a Chinese monk in Kung Fu. WTF?
    Alan Smithee
    Alan Smithee
    ...is a 20G Chamber DIETY.
    ...is a 20G Chamber DIETY.


    Male
    Join date : 2010-09-03
    Location : 40º44’18.33”N 73º58’31.82”W
    Posts : 25792
    Rep : 381

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Re: Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by Alan Smithee Sat Apr 30, 2011 5:22 pm

    captainbryce wrote:Examples where actors should never have attempted this: David Carradine, playing a Chinese monk in Kung Fu. WTF?

    Yeah but Kwai Chang Caine was bi-racial so I don't see that as such a stretch. I wonder what route the show would have taken had Bruce Lee been cast in the lead as was rumored to have been a possibility.
    Marc™
    Marc™
    …is a Chamber DEITY.
    …is a Chamber DEITY.


    Male
    Join date : 2010-01-30
    Location : Michigan
    Posts : 12006
    Rep : 212

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Re: Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by Marc™ Sat Apr 30, 2011 6:37 pm

    I don't mind actors playing out of their ethnicity....but outside their race is too extreme.
    Supernova
    Supernova
    The Book Chamber
    The Book Chamber


    Female
    Join date : 2010-06-22
    Posts : 11954
    Rep : 182

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Re: Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by Supernova Sat Apr 30, 2011 8:49 pm

    I brought this up with someone a while back, Al Pacino, an Italian, plays a Cuban, the Cuban who was Manny in Scarface played a Texas Ranger in a western, in Highlander you have a French/New York native playing a Socttish warrior, etc. Does it work? I don't know, I think so in some cases.
    JM130ELM
    JM130ELM
    …is Necessary.
    …is Necessary.


    Male
    Join date : 2010-02-02
    Location : Chicago
    Posts : 661
    Rep : 32

    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Re: Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by JM130ELM Sat Apr 30, 2011 9:05 pm

    It all depends on the asthetic of the actor. If they're physically believable for the role, I see no problem.

    Sponsored content


    Actors playing characters outside their race. Empty Re: Actors playing characters outside their race.

    Post by Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Sat Nov 23, 2024 11:18 am