I think her most overrated (by other fans) is EROTICA and her most UNDERrated is a 3way tie between BREATHLESS/BEDTIME STORIES/AMERICAN LIFE.


What do you think her most over & underrated albums are?

RobbieFTW wrote:

I think her most overrated (by other fans) is EROTICA and her most UNDERrated is a 3way tie between BREATHLESS/BEDTIME STORIES/AMERICAN LIFE.


What do you think her most over & underrated albums are?

I think that "Music" is extremely overrated. "Madonna" and "I'm Breathless" is definitely two of her underrated albums, both great albums though!

MandyPerfumeGirl wrote:

RobbieFTW wrote:

I think her most overrated (by other fans) is EROTICA and her most UNDERrated is a 3way tie between BREATHLESS/BEDTIME STORIES/AMERICAN LIFE.


What do you think her most over & underrated albums are?

I think that "Music" is extremely overrated. "Madonna" and "I'm Breathless" is definitely two of her underrated albums, both great albums though!

I think the "Music" album is slightly overrated. Don't get me wrong, "Music" is good, but it's really not one of my big favorites. "Music" is 9th on my list of Madonna's albums. Her most underrated albums I think are "American Life," "Bedtime Stories," and "I'm Breathless." I really love those albums, especially "American Life" and "Bedtime Stories."

RobbieFTW wrote:

I think her most overrated (by other fans) is EROTICA and her most UNDERrated is a 3way tie between BREATHLESS/BEDTIME STORIES/AMERICAN LIFE.


What do you think her most over & underrated albums are?

I think Confessions is overrated myself. Don't know why fans love it so much. To me it sounds like the Dance mix channel on Music Choice. Underrated is I agree Bedtime Stories and I'm Breathless. Esepecially I'm Breathless. That album really showcases her versitility as an artist. Madonna singing show tune numbers was just weird and cool all at the same time!

RobbieFTW wrote:

I think her most overrated (by other fans) is EROTICA and her most UNDERrated is a 3way tie between BREATHLESS/BEDTIME STORIES/AMERICAN LIFE.


What do you think her most over & underrated albums are?

Overrated: Confessions on a Dancefloor
Underrated: Bedtime Stories.

RobbieFTW wrote:

I think her most overrated (by other fans) is EROTICA and her most UNDERrated is a 3way tie between BREATHLESS/BEDTIME STORIES/AMERICAN LIFE.


What do you think her most over & underrated albums are?

Most overrated to me is True Blue. I say that because it sold the most and had the most hit singles, but some of it like Where's The Party, True Blue, Jimmy Jimmy, Love Makes The World Go 'Round was just embarrassingly cheesy. Most underrated is Erotica. That album is sheer euphoria!