Book burning

Chris

Chris: Chamber Admin.; Join date : 2010-01-30
Location : Oak Park, Michigan
Posts : 23201
Rep : 330

Post n°1

Book burning

by Chris Wed Apr 13, 2011 8:17 am

Do you think it ought to be illegal to burn books?

Alan Smithee

Alan Smithee: ...is a 20G Chamber DIETY.; Join date : 2010-09-03
Location : 40º44’18.33”N 73º58’31.82”W
Posts : 25792
Rep : 381

Post n°2

Re: Book burning

by Alan Smithee Wed Apr 13, 2011 8:25 am

Presuming the question relates to censorship, yes. The one exception I can think of for any censorship is the depiction of children in sexually explicit situations, AKA, child pornography. And there are some (not necessarily here) who would argue against even that.

Perhaps it was the early hour at which I first responded to the question but after re-reading it, I find that my answer needs clarification. "Should book burning be illegal?" No. Not per se. I was trying (badly) to say that books shouldn't be burned as a form of censorship by the government such as in Nazi Germany or by a school committee in the United States. Until an ammendment is made to the U.S. constitution, burning a book is just as protected as a freedom of expression as burning the U.S. flag is.

Last edited by alan smithee on Thu Apr 14, 2011 1:26 am; edited 2 times in total (Reason for editing : Clarification)

CeCe

CeCe: …is a Chamber DEITY.; Join date : 2010-06-30
Posts : 11962
Rep : 326

Post n°3

Re: Book burning

by CeCe Wed Apr 13, 2011 8:30 am

I don't think it should be illegal. I've just never seen what it really accomplishes. It might be a symbolic way of taking some kind of "stand" but it just draws attention to the book in question. Now people who weren't even interested before want to read it. If you're talking about the jackass in Florida who burned the Quran, you have to use common sense. Anyone with one functioning brain cell would know that it would spark some kind of violence. Having the right to do something doesn't mean you should do it.

RobbieFTW

RobbieFTW: …is Being Fitted For a Crown.; Join date : 2010-01-31
Location : Dearborn
Posts : 4152
Rep : 145

Post n°4

Re: Book burning

by RobbieFTW Wed Apr 13, 2011 9:42 am

There are better ways to make a point but it shouldnt be illegal.

Supernova

Supernova: The Book Chamber; Join date : 2010-06-22
Posts : 11954
Rep : 182

Post n°5

Re: Book burning

by Supernova Wed Apr 13, 2011 9:47 am

"There are worse crimes than burning books. One of them is not reading them. "
-- Joseph Alexandrovitch Brodsky, 1991, Russian-American poet, b. St. Petersburg and exiled 1972 (1940-1996)

"Every burned book enlightens the world."
-- Ralph Waldo Emerson

"Books won't stay banned. They won't burn. Ideas won't go to jail. In the long run of history, the censor and the inquisitor have always lost. The only sure weapon against bad ideas is better ideas. The source of better ideas is wisdom. The surest path to wisdom is a liberal education."
-- Alfred Whitney Griswold, Essays on Education

Shale

Shale: ...is a Chamber Royal.; Join date : 2010-09-27
Location : Miami Beach
Posts : 9699
Rep : 219

Post n°6

Re: Book burning

by Shale Wed Apr 13, 2011 9:52 am

Ironically, if governments banned the burning of books, it would be construed (and probably won in court) as infringing on our First Amendment right to free expression.

Book burning got it's bad press when the authorities, like the Catholic Church or the Nazi Party or other controlling demagogue forced the destruction of certain views.

Personally, I always thot it was stupid and counterproductive for private individuals to burn a certain record, CD or book. Again, ironically if you bot the item then destroyed it, you do not hurt the sales of that item one twit and likely increase it.